Posts

Part 2: Protect Your Time Against the Illusion of Virtue

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته We have to be incredibly careful not to fall into the trap of endless debating. It is so easy to find yourself active in a gazillion groups (WhatsApp, Telegram, and social media) completely convinced that spending hours typing back and forth is daʿwah or defending the Sunnah. But we need to check our intentions, because this is a very subtle delusion. It is the trap of trading high-value deeds, like actually memorizing the Qur’ān, pursuing structured knowledge, or rectifying your own character, for a mere illusion of productivity. It feels virtuous to win an argument online, but if it doesn't bring you closer to Allāh or build real knowledge, it produces absolutely zero fruit, and might even produce thorns tearing your deeds away. If you look at the people of actual knowledge, the scholars we claim to follow, they do not behave like this at all. At all . You will not find them camping out in comment sections or debate threads. In fact, they frequentl...

Part 1 — The Cord and the Boundary: Knowing Your Audience in Taṣwīr Discourse

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته My advice to myself and to my brothers who are convinced of the impermissibility of taṣwīr is simple: let go and move on from this issue. You seek knowledge to benefit yourself, those around you, and those who ask you. You yourself have benefited, al-ḥamdu lillāh. But those around you? Maybe not. Should you exhaust yourself responding to every single doubt they throw at you? Absolutely not. It is from lack of ḥikmah (wisdom) to not realize the type of people you are dealing with; there are two completely different categories of people: * The Common Folk : These are the people drowning in a world where modern photography is normalized. For them, accepting that taṣwīr of animate beings is ḥarām is incredibly heavy. With them, you hold the "cord of Muʿāwiyah"—you go soft, you show deep empathy, and you remain gentle to keep them connected to the truth. * The Bad-Faith Polemicists : These are the ones actively digging in the mud and fishing in murk...

It Is Just Color

Image
Working with UI design teaches you what most people never notice: Images are not objects, they're just colors arranged with intent. Nothing more, Nothing less. When you design interfaces, you spend a lot of time with color. You learn that a slight shift in hue changes what feels near and what feels distant. You learn that shadows are not captured — they are simulated, constructed from contrast. You learn that depth is a trick: two flat values of color, placed adjacently, make the eye perceive dimension that isn't there. Form emerges from color boundaries. Not the other way around. You learn this the way a carpenter learns wood. Through handling it. Through getting it wrong. Through seeing what actually happens when you change a value by ten units in one direction. Once you see that clearly, photography stops looking like "capturing reality"(1). It starts looking like what it actually is: constructing a color record of a moment(2). What comes out the other end of the c...

Don't Be So Soft With Pictures

Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 5954 ) ʿAlī bnu ʿAbdillāh narrated to us; Sufyān narrated to us; he said: I heard ʿAbdurraḥmān bnu al-Qāsim—there was no one in Madīnah at that time better than him—say: I heard my father say: I heard ʿĀʾishah, may Allāh be pleased with her, say: The Messenger of Allāh, ṣallallāhu ʿalayhi wa-sallam, returned from a journey, and I had covered a niche of mine with a thin curtain that had figures on it. When the Messenger of Allāh, ṣallallāhu ʿalayhi wa-sallam, saw it, he tore it and said: "The most severely punished on the Day of Resurrection are those who imitate the [act of] creation of Allāh". She said: So we turned it into a cushion, or two. The point of evidence: her statement: "he tore it" So, my brothers in Īmān—those who take the Messenger of Allāh, ṣallallāhu ʿalayhi wa-sallam, as their example—those who wipe only the face and leave the head; those who treat images gently, softly, leniently; those who do not feel the reprehensibility of thos...

The Digital Camera Is an Eye, a Brain, a Hand, Paint, and Canvas

Note: The following might be too technical to some, so if you don't understand it, that's okay, you don't have to. It's a way of making people realize how technology is just an advanced method of accomplishing the same tasks we've always known. The Digital Camera Is an Eye, a Brain, a Hand, Paint, and Canvas How so? • The eye : The camera lens is designed similar to the lens of the human eye, which regulates the amount and angle of incoming light. Just as a painter using a brush must open his eyes, a camera must as well allow light to enter through its lens. Then: The retina of the eye converts light into electrical neural signals, which are then transmitted to the brain. Likewise, the light sensors in a camera convert light into electrical signals that are transmitted to its internal computer—its “brain”. • The brain : The brain processes these data and enables us to perceive and comprehend what the eye has captured. There is no copied image; rather, we merely appr...

The Position of Ibn ʿUthaymīn on Image-Making By The Shaykh ʿAbdurraḥmān bnu Nāṣir al-Barrāk

The Position of Ibn ʿUthaymīn on Image-Making By the shaykh: ʿAbdurraḥmān bnu Nāṣir al-Barrāk. 18/7/1428 AH   Source: (الدرر السنية) website. Translated and prepared by: ʿAbdurraḥmān bnu Mīhūb al-Qaddārī   Introduction Abū Idrīs al-Khawlānī, رحمه الله, said: Muʿādh ibn Jabal, رضي الله عنه, said: “Ahead of you are trials in which wealth will become abundant, and the Qurʾān will be widely circulated, until it is taken up by the believer and the hypocrite, the man and the woman, the young and the old, the slave and the free. Then a person will soon say: ‘What is wrong with the people that they do not follow me, when I have recited the Qurʾān? They will not follow me until I introduce something new for them.’ So beware of newly invented matters, for whatever is invented is misguidance. And I warn you against the deviation (i.e slip) of the scholar, for indeed Shayṭān may utter a word of misguidance upon the tongue of a scholar, and a hypocrite may utter a word of truth.” He said: ...

Rule of thumb

If your screen and camera cooperate to display an animate object, you're committing photography of animate beings. Even if temporary (i.e a few seconds). The claim that "no saving occurs therefore it is not ḥarām" is invalid, because it is the same as someone drawing an animate object using a brush and paint then destroying the painting...temporary! The problem is with mere existence, no matter how short the period is.

My Methodology

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته Many have asked about my background and the approach I follow. I am a Salafī seeker of knowledge, mostly self-taught, who consults and trusts certain scholars, mainly from Ahl as-Sunnah in Yemen. I’m sharing the preface written by Shaykh Abū al-Yamān ʿAdnān al-Maṣqarī (ḥafiẓahu Allāh) for one of my works, but it also shows the methodology and manhaj I try to follow. You can also see which scholars I rely on from my posts and the things I share. May Allah guide us to benefit from knowledge sincerely for His sake. Preface by Shaykh Abū al-Yamān ʿAdnān ibn Ḥusayn al-Maṣqarī al-Yamānī May Allah preserve him الحمدُ للهِ ربِّ العالمين، أحمده سبحانه وأشكره، وأستعينه وأستغفره، وأعوذ به من شرور أنفسنا ومن سيئات أعمالنا، من يهدِه الله فلا مُضِلَّ له، ومن يُضلِل فلا هاديَ له. وأشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وحده لا شريك له، وأشهد أن محمدًا عبدُه ورسولُه، صلّى الله وسلّم وبارك عليه وعلى آله وصحبه أجمعين، ومن تبعهم بإحسان إلى يوم الدين. To proceed: The issue of image-making...

Advice and Warning to Those Who Are Lax Regarding Photography

I've observed that some use images of senior scholars, placing on them sentimental phrases, and justify this by obscuring the face. This is a corrupt practice; these images were originally produced in sin, so using them is an acknowledgment of the wrong, a habituation of the general public to it, and a step of the steps of Shayṭān. Had the photographer feared Allāh, the image would never have been taken in the first place. Is it fitting, then, that the fruit of his sin be made a medium for daʿwah? Would any of you stand before scholars and photograph them from the neck down, in their presence? The Prophet ﷺ commanded that images acquired in ignorance of the ruling be obliterated, in order to get rid of them. This, in no way, justifies seeking out images, then obscuring them, then using them in daʿwah. This is neither honoring the scholars, nor following the guidance of the Prophet ﷺ and the Salaf. Ask yourselves: would the scholar depicted consent to a post showing his body with hi...

The Narration of Jibreel Refusing To Enter the House Of The Prophet ﷺ

حدثنا عبد الرزاق، حدثنا معمر، عن أبي إسحاق، عن مجاهد، عن أبي هريرة، أن جبريل عليه السلام جاء فسلم على النبي صلى اللّه عليه وسلم، فعرف صوته، فقال: " ادخل " فقال: إن في البيت سترا في الحائط فيه تماثيل، ‌فاقطعوا ‌رؤوسها، واجعلوه بساطا أو وسائد فأوطئوه، فإنا لا ندخل بيتا فيه تماثيل". تعليق المحقق: إسناده صحيح، رجاله ثقات رجال الشيخين. مسند أحمد (8079) — ط الرسالة —. ʿAbd al-Razzāq narrated to us, Maʿamar narrated to him, from Abū Isḥāq, from Mujāhid, from Abū Hurayrah, that Jibrīl (ʿalayhi as-sallām) came and greeted the Prophet (ṣallallāhu ʿalayhi wa-sallam). Recognizing his voice, the Prophet said, “Enter”. Jibrīl then said: “There is a curtain on the wall in the house containing figures. Cut off their heads, and use it into a mat or cushions and tread upon it, for we do not enter any house in which there are figures” Scholarly editor’s note: Its isnād (narration chain) is ṣaḥīḥ (authentic), and its narrators are reliable, recognized by the two Shaykhs [al-Bukhārī and Mus...

Put That Phone Down

Some have said: We used to live the most beautiful moments without photographing them; now we photograph the most beautiful moments without living them. I say: This is an admonition even for those whom Allah has guided to recognize the prohibition of depicting animate beings. Put that phone aside. Refrain from photographing this and that, and from publishing this and that. Especially if you are among those who call to Allah, because by doing this you accustom people to waving their phones everywhere: “Shaykh so-and-so does this; don't be so strict akhi”. How many times has a shaykh photographed animate beings without paying attention, and then published it? Why place yourself in such a position? It is because you do not truly realize prohibition of tasweer and its severity, even if you think you do, whoever you may be. What sufficed those before you, and sufficed our senior scholars, should suffice you as well. We do not know of them such expansion in this matter, nor the spreading...

Clarifying the Error in the Term "Trapping Shadows"

Clarifying the Error in the Term "Trapping Shadows" ​If "shadow" refers to the darkness caused by an opaque object blocking light, then I argue the following: ​A shadow is darkness—the absence of light—and therefore contains no color. If so, where do the colors in photographs come from? Furthermore, "capturing" a shadow is impossible; a shadow isn't a physical substance you can trap, but rather a lack of one. How can one capture a void? ​If the intended meaning is "trapping light", then that is equally impossible. Light cannot be stored in its original form. Unlike heat or electricity, light is visible energy that must be converted or detected. If it were truly "trapped" as some claim, it would, by definition, no longer be visible light. ​As previously explained, a camera detects light and converts it into electrical signals via thousands of microscopic photosensors. At this stage, light rays no longer exist. If the process stopped ...

Videos Are Not Taṣweer

Anyone saying videos or video-calling is not tasweer (picture-making) has no idea what videos are nor photography in the first place. Therefore it is impressible for them to speak about the matter, as anything they would say stems from ignorance, not knowledge. Determining what videos are is not up to a faqīh, it's up to an expert in photography. Just like determining whether a medecine is dangerous or not is up to a pharmacist or a medical doctor. Please refer to experts in the matter of videos and photography, and you'll realize that none of them deny videos or photography being a modern way of making pictures. Nothing less, nothing more. It doesn't even require an expert, because it's so obvious. Every nation calls them "images". Only Muslims who say photography is permissible disagree with that. Isn't this ridiculous enough to be a wake-up call for anyone still imitating others in ignorance?

Response to Dr. Saʿd al-Khathlān on the Issue of Photography

Then he said: "But suppose that someone drew a picture of this person, and his drawing was so precise that people marveled: How could this person draw such an image?" I say: 1. People marvel at it because so few are capable of it and people are not used to it, just as they do not marvel at a calculator but are amazed at those few who can do math mentally. It is well known that one of the characteristics of modern machines is precision and the ability to repeat operations consistently. 2. Also, let us consider this phrase carefully: "and his drawing was precise". Here, the secret behind the appearance of the image as realistic was noticed, the secret being the accuracy of the drawing and the precise arrangement of colors. From this arise two possible implications:    1. Either he differentiates between the precision of human drawing and that of a machine, which is false, especially if the two results are identical.    2. Or he denies that the machine draws, traces, a...

Printing Photographs

Printing Photographs If you take a photo with a phone and then print it on paper, you cannot deny the tracing and forming required to obtain that printed image. It is well-known that the printed image is merely ink on paper, arranged by the printer. This is very clear, and it necessitates the prohibition (Taḥrīm) of such printing. Whoever prohibits printing images has fallen into a contradiction; for screens are merely a modern means of displaying images, and they are even more evil due to their superior ability to do so, which is obvious to everyone — inshāʾ Allāh. Furthermore, whoever permits printing photographs but prohibits printing hand-drawn illustrations has also fallen into a contradiction, even greater than the first. This is because both papers were produced by the same machine, on the same paper, with the same ink. It is a grave error to distinguish between them simply because the method of applying the ink has changed. Page 286 https://arm-alqaddari.codeberg.page/books/buz...

A Piece Of Advice regarding the issue of taswīr

Go easy on common folks regarding the issue if tasweer. There's a lot of falsehood out there, and the whole world has no issue with using and making pictures. It takes a considerable amount of courage to go against all of that, and join the isolated island of truth. If Allāh has not granted you tawfeeq and guidance, you'd be out there sharing memes and watching funny videos. It's quite heavy to accept that tasweer of animate beings is ḥarām, so do your best to make your advice and approach as tolerable and easy as you could. Pretend you want to keep a thin cord attached between you and them. They're already pulling so hard, so don't mirror that. Go soft. (Wisdom benefited from a narration from Mu’āwiyah, may Allāh be pleased with him. Not sure if authentic, but the meaning is correct). With that said, I feel optimistic, that this scourge will soon meet its demise, which is why I named my book what means: The Rising of the Dawn's Light, Upon the Issue of Photogra...

The ruling on photography is a disputed issue

19th Specious Argument: The ruling on photography is a disputed issue They say that it is a novel occurrence (nāzilah), and that many have issued fatwās declaring it not prohibited. The response: No—wa Rabbī! The disagreement that exists is only over the nature of photography. There is no room for juristic reasoning (ijtihād) in this matter, because it is a purely fixed, empirical scientific issue, leaving no scope for interpretation or figurative reasoning. Whoever insists on exercising ijtihād here has, in effect, passed judgment without knowledge, and this is forbidden. There is no escape from this except through repentance. By Allāh, it is astonishing how they turned away from scientific investigation into the essence of photography, and instead indulged in flimsy comparisons, weak analogies, and superficial observations, in a matter of extreme seriousness. By Allāh, a specialist in photography and computers would not need more than a few minutes to judge that these people are igno...

Differentiating between videos and photographs

15th Specious Argument: Differentiating between videos and photographs Some of them even go so far as to say: “video imaging”. The response: The matter is simple, inshā‘ Allāh. All we need to do is clarify what videos are. So what are they? If you pause a video, what do you see? An image. Play it again, then pause it. What do you see? An image. And so on. If you pause a video and then start pressing the forward and rewind buttons, you will see how it appears to you as separate, independent images. And if you press quickly, you will notice how it appears as though it is moving, even though the video itself is not playing. The conclusion? A video is a collection of images—image after image after image. Twenty-four images per second… at the very least, in our present time. It is just like hand-drawn animated flipbooks that contain a large sequence of successive drawings; when the pages are flipped rapidly, they appear to move. This technique is based on the principle of optical illusion, ...

Responding to Misused Scholarly Statements on the Ruling of Tasweer

In the Name of Allaah, the Most Merciful, the Most Compassionate. To proceed: This is a brief guide for my brothers who find it difficult to respond to the specious arguments of the common folk when they advise them about tasweer. We ask Allaah to make it a means of easing your advising people and rebuking them in this matter. And Allaah is the One whose help is sought. File link: click here To read directly:

Al-Imaam Al-Uthaymeen Did Not Say Tasweer Is Permissble In All Cases

Image
    بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته جـ - من نسب إلينا أن المحرم من التصوير هو المجسم وأن غير ذلك غير حرام فقد كذب علينا ونحن نرى أنه لا يجوز لبس ما فيه صورة سواء كان من لباس الصغار أو من لباس الكبار وأنه لا يجوز اقتناء الصور للذكرى أو غيرها إلا ما دعت إليه الضرورة أو الحاجة إليه مثل التابعية والرخصة والله الموفق . كتبه محمد الصالح العثيمين في ١١ / ٦ / ١٤١٢ هـ توقيع الشيخ هذا قول الشيخ، أو آخر أقواله. فلينصح من يحتج بقوله لتحليل التصوير، وأنه بهذا يكذب على الشيخ، وسوف يكون خصمه يوم القيامة. أتريد مجابهته أمام الله؟ الرجل جبل من الجبال، كتب الله له القبول، أتدري هول مصيبتك لو حاجك أمام الله؟ إن كنت جاهلا وبلغك هذا، فلا بأس عليك إن شاء الله، ولكن تب وتراجع وانشر الحق كما نشرت الباطل، وثوابك على الله. ---------------------- Bismillaahi ar-Rahmaani ar-Raheem, wa 'alaykum as-Salaamu wa rahmatu Allaahi wa barakaatuh A – Whoever attributed to us that what is forbidden regarding photography is only the three-dimensional (sculptural) and that other forms are not ...